In the next two posts I'll go back to the Four Greats from TSR's Pit - Larry Elmore, Jeff Easley, Keith Parkinson, and Clyde Caldwell.
I've been so focused on Frank Frazetta's art work over the last few months, but outside of my dad, these four guys remain my entry point to art, especially fantasy art. Ok, they might as well be called the Four Beards, prominent for their facial hair more than their art. Pouring over their extensive collections of paintings I see gobs of mediocre to poor work - puppet-like human figures removed from their midgrounds, meandering or thoughtless composition, lazy recycling of ideas, lack of imagination and ambition, static lethargy. Some of their stuff is embarrassingly bad, and most of that comes from their later years. It takes me back to youth being the font of creative energy. All of this said, these four artists created some amazing work that propelled TSR's Dungeons and Dragons to the height of success. They set the standard for commercial art in the 1980s. A select few of their paintings entered American cultural as icons images. I can't ignore or forget them - Elmore, Easley, Parkinson, Caldwell.
Some their their best and most loved paintings I introduced in previous posts on this blog. Here I want to hit more of their great paintings, my picks for top three paintings not yet covered for each artist, plus a few honorable mentions. I am not claiming these are their best works per say, just my favorites. I was reminded first hand at the Frazetta museum that brushwork, color, and materials of original paintings cannot be reproduced in prints, at least not the quality of prints I can my hands and eyes on.
Spell of the Winter Wizard for, a TSR 1983 Endless Quest book. This is a cool painting Elmore did early in his career at TSR when his style was looser, perhaps more free and imaginative. He took more risks.
The foundation of my knowledge of TSR's Four Greats goes back to some TSR publications we picked up in 1989. My twin brother, Leif, and I convinced my parents to buy us three art books from a game store in the Boulder's Crossroads shopping mall: The Art of Advanced Dungeons and Dragons Fantasy Game (Art of AD&D), The Art of the Dragonlance Saga. I recall that it was the preliminary design sketches in the Dragonlance art book that we used to convince our dad, who is an artist, to buy the books for us. "Look, we can learn from the sketch and design process!" We poured through these books on a weekly basis, but my favorite was the Dragonlance book. We were still reading Dragonlance novels at the time and tried our hand at running adventures in the AD&D setting using 2nd Edition rules. I loved looking at Larry Elmore's depiction of the main characters. He clearly had a special attachment to them, and indeed, was a lead designer in the original Dragonlance concept. The Dragonlance book also had paintings from Jeff Easley, Keith Parkinson, and Clyde Caldwell - the Four Greats from TSR's The Pit. I was especially drawn to the many exposed female thighs and Caldwell's bikini clad Dark Queen. My imagination and hormones ran wild.
That said, The ART of AD&D was the most revealing on the painters themselves. The Four Greats all wrote page long excerpts on their painting process and interests. The book's author/editor was Stephanie Tabat, who did production design, layout, graphics, and cartography at TSR from 1986 to 1993. Evidently she worked closely with the art team in the Pit, and she provides her insights on the each of the Four Greats, plus newbie Fred Fields, and a few other contributing artists. The book's primary focus is Elmore, Easley, Parkinson, and Caldwell. Its Tabat's writing that revealed Elmore's wife, who hard dark, curly hair, was the muse of many of his most famous works. I was fourteen when I read that. It struck me and stayed with me all these years. The Art of AD&D is a great book, well worth purchasing for fans of fantasy art. I won't spoil more of its revelations here, but I will barrow the four pencil portraits of Elmore, Easley, Parkinson, and Caldwell that accompany each of their written pieces.
Larry Elmore
Top 3 paintings covered in prior posts:2. Ancient Red, cover to the Basic D&D box set
3. Death of Sturm - Dragonlance
Top 3 and an some honorable mentions yet to be covered in this blog:
Honorable Mention: Hidden Danger, 1986 Dagon Magazine issue #108 cover
An earlyish Elmore painting. The trees are more simplified, as is the sky, showing a bit of Frazetta influence. That's not a bad thing. I think Elmore's great departures from Frazetta are his beautiful landscapes and the detail he places on clothing, weapons, and armor. Elmore does not begin to approach Frazetta in dynamic human forms, but he normally makes up for this with strong composition and beautiful natural scenery. I like this painting for three reasons: One, the composition literally has the trees grab the viewer, leading to focus on the woman's face, and yet not leaving out the crouching beast. Two, the muse in Elmore's wife is on display. Three, this is one of Elmore's few paintings or drawings in which the monster looks and feels mysterious, threatening, evil.
Honorable Mention: Weasel's Luck, 1988 Dragonlance book cover
Number Two: Test of the Twins, 1986 Dragonlance book cover
This is a controversial pick, to be sure. I'm a twin, so this one just speaks to me. Beyond that, it's the most unique of Elmore's painting compositions, and it works. Why? The composition is essentially only what is necessary to know about the two characters. Virtually everything else is left out. Elmore has three only paintings that do this, and they are all book covers for this Dragonlance Legends trilogy. The composition suits the theme and the title perfectly. Even if the viewer is unaware of the underlying story, the dichotomy between the brothers is obvious. The sword and the staff reaching upwards, and Elmore occupies that background with a beautiful sky that reflects each of the brothers personalities and stories while not distracting from them. Overall the faces, posing, and accoutrements are rather cheese cake and could fit on the cover of a romance novel, but at this point Dragonlance was drifting into romance novel territory. It fits. Finally, I just love Raistlin's eyes and Caramon's battered shield. Really well done. Elmore tried something new here as an artist, has yet to go back to it, and who knows why. I love that he did something completely different with composition and clearly poured passion into the composition, detail, and execution.
1. The Crystal Shard, 1988 Forgotten Realms book cover
This is a masterpiece! It's comes from an early Forgotten realms novel cover that launched the career of the infamous dark elf Drizzt Do'urden, seen in the middle foreground, flanked by Wulfgar to the left and Bruenor to the right. I think Elmore and author R.A. Salvatore took their queue from the Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers as Aragorn leads Legolas and Gimli the hunt for the two missing hobbits Merry and Pippin. Here I see Drizzt as Aragorn, Wulfgar as Legolas, and Bruenor as Gimli. Leave that aside though. This painting just rocks. First, the composition leads the viewer down through the faces of the characters, then to Drizzt's finger in the snow, then to the trail of blood and menacinly large footprints leading directly to the viewer. It creates story, tension, mystery. Composition doesn't get better than this. The work exudes cold. Elmore is an expert with snow, ice, and frozen rock. This is one of his best examples. The handling of the characters, the strong positioning but weight carried in different ways, and realistic integration into the overall painting is some of Elmore's very best work with human form. I think this can easily be his best painted work.
Clyde Caldwell
Top 3 paintings covered in prior posts:
1.The Elves of Alfheim, Dungeons and Dragon Gazetteer
2. Captured!
Top 3 and some honorable mentions yet to be covered in this blog:
Honorable Mention: Spellfire, 1988 Forgotten Realms book cover
This is not Caldwell's best D&D gazetteer cover (which I think is the Elves of Alfheim) but it is his first and set the tone and style for all that would follow. I think these gazetteer paintings must all start as a design concept, with a bust taking center stage, and a color scheme around that, then deciding what limited characters will populate the foreground, or maybe focusing on some map details and other bits of scenery to create the background first. I don't know, but they all tie together so well. Unusual for this first cover painting, I can't say how anything here relates to the content of the gazetteer book except for the map background. I can live with that. I love the female warrior in black leather, love the enticing gaze from the woman at center, can imagine the knight thinking I'll fight for her, or I can hang out on this cover with these ladies forever.
Number Three: Dragons of Faith, 1986 Dragonlace adventure module cover
Number Two: Dragons of Dreams, 1985 Dragonlance adventure module cover
This is a rather powerful painting of suffering, or torment. The only other work of Caldwell's that comes to mind that enters registers pain in the human subjects is the wizard Raistlin held captive by the Dark Queen in her bikini. I'm realizing that Caldwell does some really cool things with lighting in this painting. Caldwell did not need to include the dragon's hands, but that he does gives a strong sense of power over the elf king, Lorac. The contrast between the king's hand and face is striking. The overall circular composition is very compelling. There are many signature elements from Caldwell's works that just come together better here; the cobwebs hanging from the throne hint at a sense of how long the king has been trapped in his nightmare. The sparing use of the colored mist shifts the scene into a different reality. The bulbous gemstones are copied in the dragon's eye. It's a wonderful departure from most of the other Dragonlace paintings by TSR's Four Greats, and a very marked departure for Caldwell from his other work. Maybe that's why I like it so much.
1. Dragons of Despair, 1984 Dragonlance adventure module cover
I did not expect every one of my picks for Caldwell to feature dragons, nor did I think my top three paintings would all be from the original Dragonlace adventure module covers. Dragons of Despair is the first Dragonlance adventure published, and Caldwell nailed it. The composition is a little scattered, but the waterfalls do a beautiful job of drawing the gaze downward, while the columns frame the dragon. The human figures (and dwarf) are fine, but nothing special. The dragon is spectacular, the sleek, deadly positioning of the creature moves to that powerful ejection of acid from its mouth. Overall the painting bottles the spirit of this adventure like lightning, and the ruins with waterfalls tumbling out of them are absolutely fantastic. There is a lot of classic Caldwell here, from the weapon styling to the dragon's face to Goldmoon's bare thighs, but this painting also has a classically artistic and romantic feel that most of Caldwell's other paintings don't begin to approach.